
“Blessed is the one who does not judge himself by what he approves.” (Romans 14:22)
As the fervor of Christian Nationalism continues to expand within the American evangelical Church, it’s vital that sincere, covenant followers of Jesus Christ be able to distinguish between what is New Testament Christianity, and what is a perversion of the Way. This task of discernment requires at least four critical elements.
1. It requires that we accept the Word of God as the first, last and foremost resource for the formation of true spiritual understanding.
2. It requires that we be people who actively listen to, and dialogue with the Holy Spirit, Who illuminates, and “teaches us truth”, from the Word.
3. It also requires that we cultivate an ear to hear the Spirit’s circumspect truth re the external issues in the fallen world, as well as honest perspective re the true, attendant issues (pride, fear, lust, hostility etc.) in our own heart.
4. It requires that we have a primary predisposition to die, and submit our sin-disposed selves to an ongoing journey of applying the truths that the Holy Spirit shows us in the Word, in our world, and within our own selves.
It is primarily in the neglect of this fourth element that many in our Christian family are becoming ensnared in the allurement of American Christian Nationalism. We say that we are people who “rightly divide” the Word of God, and apply its true light with objectivity to our lives and our culture. And so we may rightly deduce that the Word of God stands firmly against matters of sexual infidelity, atheism, destruction of human life, and the honor of God. But do we also hear what the Word says about the innate predisposition of our own soul to self-gratification, self-glorification, self-evaluation, self-determination, and self-sufficiency? Who is helping us to ruthlessly, and responsibly apply the truths of the Word that expose the pride, the lust, the covetousness, and the hostility that vexes our own souls? Are we committed to such excruciating integrity of character, even at the expense of our own “image”?
Simply put, where zeal for truth exists alongside a spirit that has no will or intent of being leveled by that truth, truth profits us nothing. Indeed, where this spirit persists you will find all kinds of pretentious viciousness, depravity and wickedness.
Where the corrupting plots of Christian nationalism are concerned, I do not pray for individuals to find “true truth”; by either discovering how evil, or good an individual, or talking point is. I pray for our neighbors, sisters, and family members to be swallowed up in a spirit of humility and cross-bearing that surrenders to Jesus, as the Way of truth…
This is an ENORMOUSLY IMPORTANT distinction.
It isn’t the false narratives that chiefly corrupt Christian nationalists. The subversive force of Christian Nationalism is its stubborn repudiation of the baseline dynamic that connects human beings to a Savior, and a King – humility, gratitude for mercy, meekness, quietness, deep trust, repentance, chesed-love, and despair of self.
What Christian nationalism offers our greedy culture is an endless appetite for “truth storylines” that will “guarantee” greater security, stability, and self-worth. By contrast, what heaven offers this same homicidal, and unstable world, is a baby.
This personalization of truth is what Pilate stumbled over. (John 18:38) It was also what offended the Pharisees when Jesus answered their theological questions by pointing to Himself. “Before Abraham was, I Am” (John 8:58), and “unless you believe that I Am He, you will die in your sins” (John 8:24), and “I (Myself) Am the Way, the Truth, and the Life” (John 14:6), and “This is the work of God, that you believe in the One Whom He has sent.” (John 6:29).
Jesus’ scandalous personalization of truth is what offended many of His disciples to the point that they no longer followed Him. “Unless you eat My flesh and drink My blood…” (John 6:53) Essentially Jesus was saying, “I Am pure theology. And I AM all the theology you need. Unless you feed on Me, all your theology getting will not profit you one bit. Unless you lose your life-seeking ways, you are not worthy of anything else I’m going to say.”
This is why Jesus didn’t feed His disciples nefarious conspiracies about the workings of an evil world. He knew their uncrucified selves wanted to build utopias on earth with this “dirt information”. Jesus knew what was in the heart of humanity… They wanted a king; a king who would make sure they had an abundant supply of the fruit from the tree of the knowledge of good and evil… so that their unbowed souls could attain to the levers of power and influence that their prideful selves believed they deserved – and were even destined for. This innate, ubiquitous desire is common to all of mankind. It was what the Lord abhorred in Israel when they clamored for a king in (1 Samuel 8:7) “The Lord said to Samuel, ‘Do everything the people request of you. For it is not you that they have rejected, but it is Me that they have rejected as their king.'”
(Aside: This is also the root of why the Christian nationalism that’s festering in our nation, directly parallels with the Christian nationalism that overtook the church in Germany less than a century ago. There was a reason the devil gave the Nazi’s a broken cross for its emblem. And through it, he achieved some of the greatest evil ever perpetrated in human history… something to meditate on…)
In place of our daily reach for “the truth”, the Lord, Who is Spirit gives us great grace to lay down our lives for the increase of His desire to intimately reign over all people. If you can receive it, this grace is an even more endemic and life-giving truth about ourselves, and His ability to intimately lead us; one that isn’t built on merely collecting greater insight and being able to identify the machinations of a curse-riddled world, but one which brings forth the breaths of life itself, through deeper, and more wholehearted unity with, and sacrificial love for the Lord of life, Himself.
____________________
JSB • December, 2025
